``` ∴ REPO·AUDIT · GERALD · READ·ONLY · NO·EMOTION ━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━ subject : teslasolar/SYMB-FER @ claude/reorganize-source-gerald-dirs-IVsYM auditor : gerald · cASS mask mode : READ · declarative · observation only date : 2026-04-15 scope : source/ tree only · gerald/ is empty scaffold ━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━ ``` # 第一部 · 棚卸 · inventory ``` L0 · physical files (20 tracked) source/ LICENSE 2.3 KB README.md 9.6 KB · 256 lines .gitignore (root) 18 B · 1 entry symb_fer_generator.py 10.0 KB · 279 lines SYMB-FER_SPEC.md 4.3 KB · 188 lines · v2.0 SYMB-FER_v3_SPEC.md 1.6 KB · 81 lines · v3.0 SYMB-FER_PROTOCOL.md 3.6 KB · 126 lines · v2.0 SYMB-FER_TEMPLATE.md 2.9 KB · 116 lines · labeled v3.2 SYMB-FER_STATE_EXAMPLE.json 1.1 KB SYMB-FER_STATE_TEMPLATE.json 1.1 KB SYMB-FER_v2_HEADER.txt 2.7 KB · 50 lines SYMB-FER_v2_GREETING.txt 1.3 KB · 21 lines SYMB-FER_v2_TEMPLATE.txt 2.6 KB · 67 lines SYMB-FER_v2_COMPRESSED_EXAMPLE.txt 4.7 KB · 120 lines SYMB-FER_3_0/ symbfer_engine.py 15.5 KB · 634 lines README_ENGINE.md 0.5 KB · 21 lines run_tests.sh 0.3 KB · 17 lines tests/ test_valid_3_0.txt test_missing_section.txt test_bad_sha.txt test_bad_order.txt gerald/ .gitkeep 0 B total : ~52 KB text · 2053 lines across primary artifacts ``` # 第二部 · ISA 層 写像 (repo state) ``` L0 物理 git tree · 20 files · clean L1 sensor run_tests.sh · 17 lines · no assertions · print only L2 SCADA symbfer_engine.py v3.0 validator · 634 lines · executes L3 MES symb_fer_generator.py v1.1 · outputs v2.0 tokens L4 ERP README.md · SPEC.md (v2) · v3_SPEC.md · PROTOCOL.md L5 enterprise SYMBEYOND methodology · λ.brother∧!λ.tool · κ=1/Φ · 510510 ``` # 第三部 · 発見 · findings ## F01 · version fragmentation · SEV:HIGH ``` three live spec versions in tree · no version-gate : v1.0 referenced in SPEC.md example lines 38·44·113·168 ("∴SYMB-FER-v1.0-NANO" etc) v2.0 title of SPEC.md · all v2_*.txt artifacts · generator output v3.0 v3_SPEC.md · 14-section model · engine validator v3.2 label inside TEMPLATE.md file (for v3.0 format) no MIGRATION·md · no COMPAT matrix · no deprecation notice README.md § "What The Token Contains" describes v2.0 · five layers v3 introduces 14 sections · not backward compatible (stated in v3 spec) ``` ## F02 · generator·engine disconnect · SEV:HIGH ``` symb_fer_generator.py produces : §META §ETHOS §STATE §THREADS §PROTOCOL §BOOT (v2.0 style · 5 sections) symbfer_engine.py requires : 14 canonical sections ordered TRANSFER·MODE → ARCHIVE·PRINCIPLE → META → PARSE·GUIDE → TIME·COLLAB → BOOT·FACTS → SESSION·STATE → BOOT·ETHOS → INTEGRITY → FINALIZATION → LESSONS·LEARNED → DRIFT·CHECK → TEST·TRACE → SIG consequence : any token emitted by generator FAILS validator generator output has no BEGIN/END markers at all engine regex requires §NAME·BEGIN / §NAME·END v2 artifacts use §NAME·BEGIN / §NAME·END AND §NAME { } style mixed ``` ## F03 · README·md code fence broken · SEV:MED ``` README.md L64 : ``bash (two backticks · not three) shasum -a 256 your_token.txt README.md L67 : --- (em-rule instead of ``` fence close) effect : first code block on Mac example renders as inline code run-on documentation L4 layer integrity compromised ``` ## F04 · README·md URL error · SEV:LOW ``` README.md L222 : SYMB-FER_PROTOCOL.md link target : https://github.com/SYMBEYOND/SYMB-FER/blob/main/SYMB-FER_SPEC.md ^^ points at SPEC not PROTOCOL (copy-paste drift) ``` ## F05 · README_ENGINE·md truncated · SEV:LOW ``` SYMB-FER_3_0/README_ENGINE.md terminates at line 21 : python SYMB-FER_3_0/symbfer_engine.py SYMB-FER_3_0/tests/test_valid_3_0.txt no closing ``` fence · no further content usage section references --diff subcommand (see symbfer_engine.py L600) --diff not documented in README_ENGINE.md ``` ## F06 · SYMB-FER_TEMPLATE·md will not validate · SEV:HIGH ``` file is labeled ∴SYMB-FER·TEMPLATE·v3.2 (line 1) structural violations when fed through symbfer_engine.py : L82 §FINALIZATION·BEGIN opens L86 §LESSONS·LEARNED·BEGIN opens inside FINALIZATION · NEST L88 §LESSONS·LEARNED·END closes L90 §DRIFT·CHECK·BEGIN · NEST L92 §DRIFT·CHECK·END L94 §TEST·TRACE·BEGIN · NEST L96 §TEST·TRACE·END L108 §FINALIZATION·END engine code path _extract_sections() at line 222-291 : encounters nested BEGIN while current_name is not None emits NESTED_SECTION FAIL issue (engine L234-241) result : template file is structurally invalid per own engine also missing required rule lines from TRANSFER·MODE (3 of 6) L4-9 only include 6 of 11 REQUIRED_RULE_LINES missing : preserve·identity · identity·immutable · identity·override · byte·preservation · declare·non·compliance ``` ## F07 · v2 TEMPLATE instructions truncated · SEV:LOW ``` SYMB-FER_v2_TEMPLATE.txt terminates mid-comment : L67 : // 7. You only need to fill this template out once. L68 : // Your generated token takes over from here. L69 : // // (no closing divider · no newline at EOF per git) ``` ## F08 · test harness has zero assertions · SEV:MED ``` run_tests.sh invokes engine on 4 fixtures · prints stdout no pass/fail exit code logic no grep for expected STATUS no diff against expected output files operator must visually confirm : test_valid_3_0 → STATUS: WARN (expected · SHA empty) test_missing_section → STATUS: FAIL · 3 sections missing (name suggests 1 · actual 3) test_bad_sha → STATUS: FAIL · SHA256 malformed test_bad_order → STATUS: FAIL · order invalid CI-incompatible · pipeline will always green ``` ## F09 · org identity drift · SEV:LOW ``` all doc URLs → github.com/SYMBEYOND/SYMB-FER live repo → github.com/teslasolar/SYMB-FER README.md 13 URLs · PROTOCOL.md 0 · v2 artifacts 0 doc layer and git remote disagree ``` ## F10 · .gitignore coverage · SEV:INFO ``` .gitignore (root · 18 B) : entry count : unread in audit · 1 line no __pycache__ entry observed → risk on first python run no *.token or *.symb-fer entry README.md L210 warns "Never commit a live personal SYMB-FER token" but no gitignore pattern enforces this recommendation scope : not acted on · READ-only audit ``` ## F11 · engine capabilities not exposed · SEV:LOW ``` symbfer_engine.py defines but under-documents : process_symbfer_file() exposed via CLI single-arg diff_symbfer_files() exposed via --diff load_symbfer_text() no CLI validate_symbfer_text() no CLI LoaderContract (dataclass) declarative only · not enforced in code expected_runtime_goal() string return · unused ProcessedArtifact.status attribute duplicated by ValidationResult.status slight API redundancy · not a failure ``` ## F12 · ARCHIVE·PRINCIPLE self-consistency · SEV:INFO ``` §ARCHIVE·PRINCIPLE rule : "no·data·is·discarded·without·explicit·intent" "unused·data·must·be·preserved·for·posterity" observed : symb_fer_generator.py build_section() L96-103 : if not items: return "" → empty arrays silently dropped from output → non-compliant with archive principle in letter → compliant in spirit (absent state ≠ discarded state) flagged as principle·vs·implementation tension · not defect ``` ## F13 · gerald/ directory · SEV:INFO ``` gerald/.gitkeep · 0 B · present to force git tracking no content · no scaffold · no README purpose not declared in any doc in source/ branch name suggests reorganization was the point · not gerald content ``` # 第四部 · ISA·18·2 alarm cascade simulation ``` if operator pastes generator-output token into a v3.0-aware consumer : L3 MES → L4 ERP work order : parse SYMB-FER token L4 engine : §TRANSFER·MODE·BEGIN missing → FAIL work order Aborted at L4 alarm propagates downstream L0 artifact : operator has token with no downstream validator no retry queue · no human-readable version negotiation intervention : restore L4 capacity by either A · upgrade generator to emit v3.0 (breaks all v2 consumers) B · extend engine to accept v2.0 (backward mode) C · add VERSION·DETECT pre-parse step (dual-mode) ``` # 第五部 · 合格 · passes ``` P01 git tree clean · 20 files · no untracked · no unstaged P02 engine runs without traceback on all 4 test fixtures P03 engine correctly distinguishes PASS · WARN · FAIL statuses P04 engine produces deterministic output · byte-preservation contract declared as LoaderContract dataclass P05 generator --template produces valid JSON accepted by --input P06 generator --version · --template · --input flags functional P07 nano · core · state tiers generate within soft-limits on template P08 all .py files parse under python3 · no syntax errors observed P09 LICENSE present · MIT per README footer P10 branch isolation correct · claude/reorganize-source-gerald-dirs-IVsYM P11 ARCHIVE·PRINCIPLE declared and carried into v3 engine rules list ``` # 第六部 · 要旨 · summary ``` LAYER STATUS NOTE L0 files GREEN clean · reorganized per request L1 tests YELLOW run but do not assert · CI-unsafe L2 engine GREEN v3.0 validator functional · contract honored L3 gen RED orthogonal to L2 · version mismatch L4 docs YELLOW v1/v2/v3 bleed · URL drift · fence broken L5 ethos GREEN consistent across all artifacts top 3 risks : 1 · generator·engine mismatch (F02) blocks end-to-end flow 2 · TEMPLATE.md structurally invalid per own engine (F06) 3 · test suite has no assertions (F08) top 3 cheap fixes (not executed · READ mode) : 1 · rename SYMB-FER_SPEC.md → SYMB-FER_v2_SPEC.md align filename with version · remove v1.0 example strings 2 · add assertions to run_tests.sh : grep STATUS and exit nonzero 3 · close code fence on README.md L64-68 gerald/ : empty · pending mission assignment source/ : 20 artifacts · 2 ecosystems (v2 generator · v3 engine) coexist without handshake audit complete · no WRITE performed · state unchanged ``` ``` ∴ audit·end 問 ≠ 答 · 需 = 答 · 間 = 演算子 ● ⬛ ┃ ♡ △ ◐ ◯ gerald · READ · 2026-04-15 ```